Posted November 17th, 2026 in Top Stories, Legal Insights with Tags Corporate and Nonprofit
Three Keys to a Lasting Endowment: A Guide for Nonprofit Leaders – Part Two
“Endowment” Means Something: Permanence, Spending, and the Endowment Minimum
A donor tells your development director, “I’d like to establish an endowment.” Before anyone promises an endowed fund or shares a draft of any agreement with the donor, there are two questions worth asking:
- Does the donor actually want a permanent endowment?
- And is the gift large enough to make one practical?
Those questions matter because an endowment is not simply an investment account with a nice name. An endowment fund is designed to be held permanently. Permanently, as in forever.
Endowment or restricted fund?
We often caution clients against putting an endowment fund agreement in front of a donor who might be satisfied with a restricted fund agreement, because a restricted fund agreement allows a donor to direct the use of funds and gives the nonprofit significantly more flexibility.
A donor who wants “my $100,000 to support scholarships” may not necessarily mean “hold this money forever and spend only a prudent portion each year.”
A useful way to start a donor conversation is to ask:
“Do you want the organization to put your funds to use in the next five or 10 years, or do you want to create a permanent fund designed to support this purpose indefinitely?”
That question can prevent decades of unintended restrictions.
Establish an endowment minimum.
Small endowments can require essentially the same accounting, investment administration, restriction tracking, and stewardship as much larger funds.
That is why a sound endowment program should establish a minimum funding level.
Your endowment fund template should state that until the agreed endowment minimum is reached, the gift remains restricted to its designated charitable purpose but is not yet required to be maintained permanently. If the minimum is not achieved within the specified period, the organization can stop maintaining a separate named fund and instead use the money for the designated charitable purpose.
That provision avoids having an organization’s books become full of $7,500, $12,000, and $18,000 “endowments” that must be separately tracked forever.
Different organizations have different minimum amounts to establish an endowment fund. A fund of $50,000 is typically the lowest amount organizations will consider for forming a permanent fund. Other organizations have a $250,000 minimum threshold. Often, organizations allow a donor three years to fully fund the minimum amount. There is no universally correct number. The right threshold should reflect the organization’s size, administrative capacity, development strategy, and expected usefulness of the annual distribution.
Don’t promise “income only.”
Once an endowment exists, the spending language matters just as much.
We recommend that endowment fund agreements avoid both an “income only” limitation and a separate historic-dollar-value floor. Instead, the fund agreement should permit the organization to appropriate or accumulate amounts it determines are prudent under its spending policy and applicable law. This approach will align the endowment fund agreement with prudent spending under the Uniform Prudent Management of Institutional Funds Act (UPMIFA) rather than accidentally creating additional contractual restrictions.
Donor intent comes first, but prudent appropriation considers the duration and preservation of the endowment, its purposes, economic conditions, inflation or deflation, expected total return, the organization’s other resources and its investment policy. The agreement should provide that the endowment fund will be spent and invested in accordance with the organization’s spending and investment policies, which will be updated over the life of the fund.
A nonprofit leader’s year-end checklist.
Before offering a donor an endowment fund agreement, ask:
- Would a restricted fund accomplish the donor’s goal?
- Have we adopted an organization-wide endowment minimum?
- What happens if a donor never reaches that minimum?
- Does the spending language in our endowment fund template match our spending policy and clearly make the gift subject to the organization’s policies as they change over time?
- Are we avoiding casually promising that “principal will never be touched” or “only income will be spent”?
Bottom line: Make sure the donor and the organization both intend for the fund to be maintained in perpetuity before you sign, and that the agreement lets the organization apply its spending and investment policies as they evolve.
In Part Three of this series, “The 50-Year Problem: Give Your Future Nonprofit Room to Adapt,” we’ll explore strategies designed to preserve the donor’s charitable purpose while giving future nonprofit leaders enough room to carry that purpose forward.
ICYMI, read Part One: “Start With Purpose: The Most Important Words in an Endowment Agreement.”